All they have is what they call a theory

A Lesson in Discoveroid Quote

canada goose black friday sale The Discovery Institute recently canada goose outlet usa gave us A Lesson in Discoveroid Debate Tactics. Today at their creationist blog they giving us a lesson in quote canada goose outlet locations in toronto mining a traditional creationist technique. Here are some excerpts, with bold font added by us for emphasis: canada goose black friday sale

canada goose store The ruins of Mayan civilization impress anyone who canada goose outlet 2015 visits. For Harvard astronomer Avi Loeb, they spoke to him about the philosophy of science then and now. Recounting his experience for Nature, he describes the canada goose outlet parka questions that came to his mind: canada goose store

canada goose coats This is Loeb article in Nature: Good data are not enough. You can read it online without a subscription. canada goose coats uk The title alone is sufficient canada goose outlet legit to excite a creationist, assuming they canada goose outlet uk sale willing to ignore the fact that their buy canada goose uk of intelligent design has no supporting data whatsoever. canada goose coats

cheap Canada Goose Nothing in Loeb article even hints that he a creationist, or that he has any sympathy for the Discoveroids. He says and the Discoveroids quote this: cheap Canada Goose

canada goose clearance sale The Mayans accurately tracked changes in the positions and relative brightness of the Sun, canada goose outlet in vancouver Moon, planets and stars. They documented their astronomical data in folding books called codices, with many more quantitative details than other civilizations at canada goose outlet store near me the time. The priest astronomers used observations and advanced mathematical canada goose outlet uk calculations canada goose outlet vip to predict eclipses, and devised a 365 day solar calendar canada goose outlet boston that was off by canada goose outlet woodbury just one month every 100 years. canada goose clearance sale

buy canada goose jacket cheap But after noting that, he says this and the Discoveroids quoted only the bit we put in red font: buy canada goose jacket cheap

I came to appreciate how limiting canada goose outlet 80 off prevailing world views can be. Just as geological and canada goose outlet shop other evidence for the great age of Earth was rejected before the nineteenth century as being hard to square canada goose uk site with biblical history, the Mayans used their fine data to support a mythological culture of astrology. They correlated the periodic motions canada goose outlet store uk of celestial objects with human history and, rather than seeking a physical explanation for their astronomical data, they used it to initiate wars or rituals such canada goose parka outlet uk as human sacrifice.

Canada Goose Coats On Sale In other words canada goose outlet , Loeb canada goose outlet store toronto says that for all the Mayans admirable efforts to gather data, their understanding canada goose outlet store montreal of that data was distorted by Oogity Boogity. The Discoveroids, however, canada goose outlet in montreal merely quote the part about limiting prevailing canada goose discount uk world views can be. Isn quote mining wonderful? Canada Goose Coats On Sale

uk canada goose outlet Okay, back to the Discoveroids, as they selectively relate what Loeb says: uk canada goose outlet

Canada Goose online In their day, Mayan astronomers were held in high social esteem. So are today astronomers. Loeb thought about how today collect vast amounts of exquisite data in surveys of large parts of the sky, costing billions of dollars. But Good data are not enough, he realized. Canada Goose online

canadian goose jacket Actually, Loeb never says data are not enough. It merely the title of the article. Before we continue with the Discoveroids quote mining efforts, you probably wondering just what it is about our worldview that Loeb is complaining about. He rambles a bit, but this probably sums it up fairly well: canadian goose jacket

I noticed this bias recently while assessing a PhD thesis. The student was asked to test whether canada goose jacket outlet a data set from a large cosmological survey was in line with canada goose jacket outlet sale the standard cosmological model. But when a canada goose outlet authentic discrepancy was found, the student goal shifted to canada goose outlet toronto location explaining why the canada goose outlet toronto factory data set canada goose outlet new york was incomplete. In such a culture, the current model can never be ruled out, even though everyone knows that its major constituents canada goose parka outlet (dark matter, dark energy and inflation) are not understood at canada goose outlet online uk a fundamental level. Instead https://www.salecanadagooseoutlets.com/ , observers should present results in a theory neutral way. Observations should not converge on one model but aim to find anomalies that carry clues about the nature of dark matter, dark energy or initial conditions of the canada goose outlet reviews Universe.

Observe, dear reader, that nothing Loeb says even remotely challenges the refusal of science to consider supernatural explanations. The Discoveroids, however, would have us think otherwise. They say:

Canada Goose Parka What might have helped the Mayans break out of the box of their prevailing world view? He [Loeb] hit upon a solution that should be of great interest to the intelligent design community. Canada Goose Parka

Canada Goose Online The consequences of a closed scientific culture are wasted resources and misguided witness the dead end that was Soviet evolutionary biology. To truly move forward, free thought must be encouraged outside the mainstream. Multiple interpretations of existing data and alternative motivations for collecting new data must canada goose outlet online reviews be supported. Canada Goose Online

canada goose Yes, Loeb said that, but not to encourage scientists to consider intelligent design. Rather, Loeb said: canada goose

canada goose uk shop How each culture views the Universe is guided by its beliefs in, for example, mathematical beauty or the structure of reality. If these ideas are deeply rooted, people tend canada goose victoria parka outlet to interpret all data as supportive of them adding parameters or performing mathematical gymnastics to force the fit. Recall how the canada goose outlet winnipeg address belief that the Sun moves around Earth led to the mathematically beautiful (and incorrect) theory of canada goose outlet price epicycles advocated by the ancient Greek philosopher Ptolemy. Similarly, modern cosmology is augmented by unsubstantiated, mathematically sophisticated ideas of the multiverse, anthropic reasoning and string theory. canada goose uk shop

canada goose clearance All that Loeb seems to be saying is that researchers shouldn fall in love with one theory, and then try to cram their data into it. That sound advice, but it of no help to the Discoveroids canada goose outlet near me unless they distort it. They do so near the end of their post: canada goose clearance

Canada Goose sale Think about what ID has to offer the admittedly stagnant field of consensus cosmology: Canada Goose sale

uk canada goose Theory of information: its source and conservation uk canada goose

Canada Goose Jackets A cause to explain the fine tuning of the universe Canada Goose Jackets

canada goose coats on sale Philosophy of science unlimited by naturalism canada goose coats on sale

buy canada goose jacket A different vocabulary and comfort zone buy canada goose jacket

canada goose uk black friday Observe, dear reader, what the Discoveroids don offer which is data. All they have is what they call a theory, an alleged cause, a supernatural philosophy, and a different vocabulary. They end with this, presumably addressed to Loeb: canada goose uk black friday

Canada Goose Outlet But while the rise and fall of Mayan official canada goose outlet civilization is on his mind, leading him to ponder modern cosmology potential for worldview blindness, the time seems right to engage the discussion. Canada Goose Outlet

cheap canada goose uk Somehow, we suspect that Loeb will decline the Discoveroids invitation. The Sensuous Curmudgeon. cheap canada goose uk

canada goose uk outlet Let take these one at a time, shall we? (Ignoring about math, which is a touch too vague to comment on.) canada goose uk outlet

canada goose factory sale (1) Theory of information: This poor spavined old workhorse of creationism is long overdue for the glue factory. can indeed be created; canada goose outlet houston it only within an absolutely closed system, which the planet Earth is canada goose parka uk not canada goose factory sale.

No comments

You can be the first one to leave a comment.

Post a Comment